Issue link: https://www.epageflip.net/i/233382
Thursday, December 26, 2013 – Daily News 3B To clean up coal, Obama pushes more oil production DE KALB, Miss. (AP) — America's newest, most expensive coal-fired power plant is hailed as one of the cleanest on the planet, thanks to governmentbacked technology that removes carbon dioxide and keeps it out of the atmosphere. But once the carbon is stripped away, it will be used to do something that is not so green at all. It will extract oil. When President Barack Obama first endorsed this ''carbon-capture'' technology, the idea was that it would fight global warming by sparing the atmosphere from more greenhouse gases. It makes coal plants cleaner by burying deep underground the carbon dioxide that typically is pumped out of smokestacks. But that green vision proved too expensive and complicated. So the administration accepted a tradeoff. To help the environment, the government allows power companies to sell the carbon dioxide to oil companies, which pump it into old oil fields to force more crude to the surface. A side benefit is that the carbon gets permanently stuck underground. The program shows the ingenuity of the oil industry, which is using government green-energy money to subsidize oil production. But it also showcases the environmental trade-offs Obama is willing to make, but rarely talks about, in his fight against global warming. Companies have been injecting carbon dioxide into old oil fields for decades. But the tactic hasn't been seen as a pollutioncontrol strategy until recently. Obama has spent more than $1 billion on carboncapture projects tied to oil fields and has pledged billions more for clean coal. Recently, the administration said it wanted to require all new coal-fired power plants to capture carbon dioxide. Four power plants in the U.S. and Canada planning to do so intend to sell their carbon waste for oil recovery. Just last week, former Energy Secretary Steven Chu announced he was joining the board of a company developing carbon AP photo In this photo taken Oct. 22, work continues at Denbury Resources Inc.'s, Tinsley Facility in Tinsley, Miss. Denbury Resources hopes to bring new life to old oil fields by pumping in carbon dioxide to force additional oil to the surface. Denbury Resources hopes to bring new life to old oil fields by pumping in carbon dioxide to force additional oil to the surface. The nearby Southern Compnay's Kemper County power plant, America's newest, most expensive coal-fired power plant is hailed as one of the cleanest on the planet, thanks to government-backed technology that removes carbon dioxide and keeps it out of the atmosphere. Once the carbon is stripped away, it will be used to do something that is not so green at all – extract oil. Denbury is one company that uses this process. capture technology. The unlikely marriage of coal burners and oil producers hits a political sweet spot. It silences critics who say the administration is killing coal and discouraging oil production. It appeases environmentalists who want Obama to get tougher on coal, the largest source of carbon dioxide. It also allows Obama to make headway on a second-term push to tackle climate change, even though energy analysts predict that few coal plants will be built in the face of low natural gas prices and Environmental Protection Agency rules that require no controls on carbon for new natural gas plants. ''By using captured man-made carbon dioxide, we can increase domestic oil production, promote economic development, create jobs, reduce carbon emissions and drive innovation,'' Judi Greenwald told Congress in July, months before she was hired as deputy director of the Energy Department's climate, environment and energy efficiency office. Before joining the Ener- gy Department, Greenwald headed the National Enhanced Oil Recovery Initiative, a consortium of coal producers, power companies and state and environmental officials promoting the process. But the environmental benefits of this so-called enhanced oil recovery aren't as certain as the administration advertises. ''Enhanced oil recovery just undermines the entire logic of it,'' said Kyle Ash of Greenpeace, one of the few environmental groups critical of the process. ''They can't have it both ways, but they want to really, really bad.'' That has become a theme in some of Obama's green-energy policies. To promote new, cleaner technologies, the administration has allowed companies to do things it otherwise would oppose as harmful to the environment. For wind power, the government has shielded companies from prosecution for killing protected birds with giant turbines. For corn-based ethanol, the administration underestimated the environmental effects of millions of new acres of corn farming. The government even failed to conduct required air and water quality studies to document its toll on the environment. The administration wants to make similar concessions to make carboncapture technology a success. The EPA last week exempted carbon dioxide injection from strict hazardous waste laws. It classified the wells used to inject the gas underground for oil production in a category that offers less protection for drinking water. Oil companies using carbon to get oil also aren't subject now to the tougher reporting and monitoring requirements that experts say are necessary to ensure the carbon stays underground, and they're fighting an EPA proposal that would require them to be if the carbon comes from power plants covered by the new federal rules. ''It amounts to looking the other way,'' said George Peridas, a scientist with the Natural Resources Defense Council, which supports using carbon for oil extraction. The group believes it replaces dirtier oil or oil produced in more environmentally sensitive places and reduces carbon in the atmosphere. The administration also did not evaluate the global warming emissions associated with the oil production when it proposed requiring power plants to capture carbon. A 2009 peer-reviewed paper found that for every ton of carbon dioxide injected underground into an oil field, four times more carbon dioxide is released when the oil produced is burned. ''There is no form of energy that is free of impacts. It is always about trade-offs and someone will always be unhappy,'' the paper's author, Paulina Jaramillo, the assistant professor at Carnegie Mellon University, said in an interview. Administration officials counter by saying the oil was going to be extracted anyway, so the policy should only be seen as reducing carbon dioxide from coal plants. The administration also promotes the benefits for energy security. Every bar- rel of oil produced here will mean one less produced abroad. ''We are taking carbon dioxide that would have gone to the atmosphere in coal plants, storing it and displacing imported oil with domestic oil,'' said Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz, asking a question posed by The Associated Press on C-SPAN's ''Newsmakers'' program in September. In Mississippi, where Southern Company's Kemper County power plant eventually will supply two oil producers with carbon dioxide, Denbury Resources Inc. says it would not be able to produce oil there otherwise. Denbury is already using carbon dioxide trapped beneath a salt dome near Jackson to produce oil in the state. But it can use more carbon dioxide than nature can provide. That's where the power plant comes in. The federal support for Kemper lowers the cost of installing the carbon capture equipment, and ultimately, the cost of carbon dioxide for the oil producer. The company has entered into a long-term contract with Southern for carbon dioxide. It will permit Denbury to recover a total of between 3.5 million and 4.2 million barrels of oil, a tiny fraction of the 91 million barrels of oil the world consumed daily last month. But for the oil companies, it still means millions of dollars more in revenue. The nearly $5-billion project received $270 million from the Energy Department, prior to the Obama administration, and $279 million more in federal tax credits. A member of Mississippi's Public Service Commission, Brandon Presley, bristled over what he described as pressure from Washington to approve the project, which already has meant a 15 percent increase in utility bills for Mississippi Power customers. Secretary Chu wrote Presley a letter in May 2010 that said without the Kemper County project, the U.S. government might not be able to use the technology anywhere. The commission approved it over Presley's objection. See COAL, page 4B HOME SERVICES DIRECTORY TWO SIZES TO CHOOSE FROM Full Size $ Online: Publishes 24/7 Print and On-Line Half Size 112 67 $ Per Month .50 Per Month No early cancellation, non-refundable Need Blinds? C P A A L U L L Paul Stubbs 527-0842 North State Blinds & Draperies www.nsbd.biz Lic.#906022 In Print Every Tuesday - Thursday - Saturday Advertisement Clock Repair Construction Contractor R. G. SIDES If this was your Service Directory ad customers would be reading it right now!! Call us at Grandpa's Clocks Burrows Construction When you want it done right ... Your Repair & Remodeling Expert • Room Additions • Framing • Full Service Concrete Work and Foundations • Electrical Work, New and Repairs • Plumbing Work • Drywall Installation • Tape/Texture • Trim/Crown Molding • Doors & Hardware • Windows & Skylights • New Roof Comp. • Concrete Work, Colored Overlays • Retaining Wall, Concrete or Block • Masonry Work • Fences • Buildings • Small Jobs • Tile Work, Bathrooms, Kitchens, Counter Tops, Floors, Shower Pans & Walls Office 530-527-7256 Cell # 530-209-9999 527-2151 Advertisement on House Remodel / Specialist Rental Turnovers / Repairs Bathroom Remodels / Tile Painting • Electrical • Plumbing • Drywall Repairs • Fences • Decks • Concrete • Garages Quality at a reasonable price FREE ESTIMATES 530 949-6162 CA LIC#914460 If this was your Service Directory ad customers would be reading it right now!! Call us at 527-2151 For more information Your Clock Repair Shop Jim Paul 20910 Pebblestone Dr. Red Bluff 530-736-7079 Mechanical, Battery and Electrical clocks For more information Call for appt. Residential • Commerical PATIOS • DECKS Remodel, New Additions, Siding Repair and Replacement, Water and Dryrot Damage Specialist, New Construction Foundation to Finish REFRENCES Lic#824770 HIRE A LICENSED CONTRACTOR! Complete directory of Tehama County contractors online, listed by specialty on www.RedBluffDailyNews.com Click on 2011 Contractors Guide under "Special Sections" Member NAWCC Lic.#639360 Alle Three additional online locations at no extra cost! Building Construction Blinds Construction ns Constructi www.redbluffdailynews.com Drywall Patchman Drywall Repairs & Texturing 20 Years Exp. Professional Resonable • No Mess Residential or Commercial Michael Johnson 530-227-8230 Business Lic #27732 Firearm Instruction Clarence Davis NRA Certified Firearm Instruction Concealed Carry Initial & Renewal Classes (530) 529-4224 Ph: (530) 515-9779 Landscaping Landscape/Fence Advertisement Green again landscaping Steve's Tractor If this was your Service Directory ad customers would be reading it right now!! Call us at 527-2151 For more information HONEST & DEPENDABLE ★ LAWN SERVICE ★ WEED EATING ★ HEADING ★ GUTTER CLEANING ★ TREE TRIMMING ★ FIRE BREAKS Scott West (530) 566-7951 & Landscape Service • Fence Building • Landscaping • Trenching • Rototilling • Disking • Mowing • Ridging • Post Hole Digging • Blade Work • Sprinkler Installation • Concrete Work Cont. Lic. #703511 Steve Dyke 385-1783 Advertisement If this was your Service Directory ad customers would be reading it right now!! Call us at 527-2151 For more information